My daughter is 3 and I finally got around to opening an official college savings account for her.
I blame myself for being slow but I also blame the system our government created for being overly complicated and obtuse.
After doing my research, I decided to start with an ESA account because of one thing: I can invest in anything I want. I have total control. I will also need to use a 529 plan because we need to save more than $2k/year but I have put the decision about which plan (and which type of plan) off for now.
What I want is a larger ESA plan but all I ever hear about is 529 plans. Why?
First off, ESA accounts are capped to $2,000 of savings a year. Again, I ask why?
My first instinct is to follow the money and my first guess is that the government (paid off by the industry) push 529 plans because it means more jobs for the financial industry.
529 plans are free money for investment funds and every state has at least two funds. Those state funds just funnel money into a handful of investment companies (Schwab, Fidelity, etc) who collectively take in billions of dollars with little or no oversight. Their customer is state governments not individual savers.
Customers, like myself, put money into the fund and have little to no say about how the money is spent.
We are given a very small set of investment options to choose from. (Who picks those?)
In many funds we are limited to a single allocation change per year. Yes, I said YEAR!
You read the newspaper and see the financial bubble and meltdown coming? Well good luck doing anything about it in a 529 plan; you get to ride it out.
You think you are saving for college but in reality you are just creating jobs for investment companies who get to manage billions of dollars of dumb money. After all, the best customer is a silent, powerless customer.
I can see the industry arguing that this a "fire and forget" strategy for savings. Most people dont have the time or skills to evaluate investments so they will do it for us.
That is a good argument but they should also offer a self-managed fund.
The ESA limits and 529 limits should be equal. If you want to trust in your anonymous brokers, go for it but let me invest in myself.
We dont have that system so I suspect self-interest at work on the political process.
And recent news indicates that a lot of people are pulling money out of 529 plans for just this lack of control. Why should we support a system we feel is flawed?
More Parents Are Becoming 529 Dropouts
Investors and Advisers Seek More-Flexible Options in Wake of Market Turmoil
Wall Street Journal
11-11-09
"Any new money going to my kids' college education is going into something that I manage myself," he said. "I know I could do better and I can be safer."
In recent years, 529 plans have been pitched as the ultimate college-savings vehicle. The plans are sponsored by states, and their investment options and fees can vary widely.
But in the wake of last year's market collapse and some high-profile fund blowups, some investors—and financial advisers—are paring back their reliance on 529 plans and in some cases are considering alternatives. After tucking some $15.5 billion into 529s in 2006 and an additional $15.2 billion in 2007, investors contributed an estimated $5.2 billion last year, according to Financial Research Corp., a Boston research firm owned by Mercatus Partners LLC. So far this year, investors have put an estimated $4.8 billion into the plans.
I have the same complaints about 401k plans. Again, their customer is the corporation/employer not the employee/saver. And the result is poor selection and lack of control. But that is another post for another day.






